The comic begins right at the very last scene of The Superior Foes of Spider-Man #9, after which Beetle and Overdrive have commandeered a school bus full of kids that has been damaged by ninja-style weaponry, and are confronting Boomerang over having sold them out and leaving them for dead after the raid on the Owl's headquarters. Boomerang tries to change the subject by asking why Overdrive tricked out a school-bus, why a fifth-grader is brandishing a sword, to which Overdrive briefly explains that he owes money to Mr. Negative for him giving Overdrive his powers, that his forces attacked them, and that he stole a school-bus because he didn't have a lot of options to get away.
Beetle is about to blast Boomerang to which he responds that it wasn't him, but the Chameleon. He then goes on to claim that while he was in jail with the Chameleon, they didn't get along. So when the others came to bail him out, the Chameleon sucker-punched him and, when he came to, he found himself on a fishing barge with an ID chip in his back—which Overdrive points out is the plot from The Bourne Identity--while the Chameleon took his place. Beetle and Overdrive don't believe him, especially after Boomerang let's it slip that “the Chameleon” killed Shocker instead of “chickening out” and quitting like he told them. However, before Beetle can kill Boomerang, the Owl shows up and, having been convinced it was the Chameleon that stole the Dr. Doom painting, that Boomerang is telling the truth. Beetle and Overdrive, frustrated, decide to leave, but when the Owl offers them a job, they decide to stick around.
We then return to Boomerang as he explains the layout of the Chameleon's hideout and the traps therein –exactly like he did for the Owl's hideout back in The Superior Foes of Spider-Man #5—only for Beetle to say they are not falling for that trick again, pointing out that he's already screwed them over once and that now they're working for the Owl who just hour earlier tried to have them killed. Boomerang, however says they're not actually going to go after the painting for the Owl, that they'll use the Owl and his firepower as a distraction to take the painting for themselves. Beetle points out this is exactly what Boomerang did to them when robbing the Owl, but Boomerang insists it'll be different because, unlike last time, they'll be a team, and that the score will be enough for Beetle to start her own empire and for Overdrive to pay off his debts to Mr. Negative.
When Boomerang inquires about Speed Demon, Overdrive texts him and Speed Demon arrives. Beetle notices Speed Demon has been crying, and while Speed Demon denies it, he's thinking about Inspector the dog. When Boomerang explains to Speed Demon that the team is back together, Beetle says they haven't agreed to anything yet. However, the Owl, having overheard this, point outs that any one who chooses to leave run the risk of violating the terms of their “nondisclosure appropriate anticipatory actions, etc.” and, this time, Beetle won't be able to call her dad, Tombstone, to held them out. Owl also says he's brought Boomerang a visitor—his bartender girlfriend. Upon seeing Boomerang, the bartender rolls up her sleeve, punches him in the face, and tells him “Don't ever call me again” as she storms out. Then the Owl takes Boomerang to introduce to him the new members of his gang, as Boomerang requested more villains for the job, which includes The Fly, Mountain Man Marko, Mirage, The Armadillo, Shriek, Cyclone, The Squid, Clown from the Ringmasters of Crime, Bi-Beast, Scorcher, the Kangaroo, and the Spot. And with Boomerang, Beetle, Speed Demon, and Overdrive, the Sinister Six has now become The Sinister Sixteen!
Back at the Shocker's apartment, Shocker is stressed over the fact that Hydro-Man, who he considered a friend, has betrayed him. Silvermane, however, points out that Shocker's “friends” are criminals, and that Boomerang, who was also supposedly Shocker's friend as well, also betrayed him by stuffing his body in a car trunk and pushing it off a bridge. Shocker says that there's supposed to be a code, that gangs are like a “family” and that they're supposed to stick together. Silvermane says that even when he was the head of the Maggia crime family, he never trusted any of his people, and that the stuff about “family” was just another way to keep them in line and that “only the saps buy it.” He adds that the only way to stay alive in the business is to make others fear you, and tells Shocker, “Who would ever fear a nobody like you.”
At this, Shocker goes over to his closet and gets out a bowling bag. Then, removing the bowling ball, stuffs Silvermane's head into the bag. Shocker then vows he won't get screwed over again, that he's through playing the nice guy and the team player, then angrily throws the bowling ball out the window, vowing he's going to give those who double-crossed him something to be afraid of. Outside, waiting on the street, are Hammerhead and his goons, ready to charge into the apartment building, guns drawn and loaded.
Oh, Nick Spencer and Steve Lieber—how we've missed you! More than that, as Boomerang's sly, metatextual comment in the beginning suggests, not only have we been waiting for “a really long time,” but we actually got a genuine issue of Superior Foes, something which is very welcome in light of the disastrous and pointless filler that was last issue. As this issue reminds us, it was never just the fact that what makes Superior Foes so good is that it's merely a funny look at Marvel's less notable villains. It was because Spencer and Lieber were able to effectively use verbal and visual gags in subtle and creative ways to show character without actually demeaning them. Thus, reading this issue was very much like a “greatest hits” compilation of the best gags of issue's past. However, like all “Greatest Hits” compilations, that can have its downsides.
This is why I thought the main story involving Boomerang once again conning his fellow teammates and the Owl the steal back the Doctor Doom painting from the Chameleon didn't feel as strong as it could have been. Granted, the point is that Fred is using almost the same tactics to pull off almost the same con, but this also means running the risk of making the humor feel recycled. Just like the other characters have become wiser to Fred's methods, so too have the readers when it comes to the punchlines Spencer and Lieber are employing. Which is why when we learn that everything Boomerang has done since Superior Foes #1 has all been an elaborate scheme just to rob to paltry contents of the Chameleon's safe winds up working as well as it does. Because even though we, like the characters, are starting to get wise to the act, there is always one more trick up Boomerang's—and Spencer and Lieber's—sleeve to keep us on our toes. Not to mention, it's the most revealing insight into Boomerang as a character yet, because for all of his elaborate scheming and convincing himself that he's a genuine criminal mastermind, Fred really is nothing more than a petty crook. After all, his master plan to rob the Chameleon is akin to getting rid of ant hill with a bazooka.
One thing I do worry about is, because we've had two interruptions on this series in a row whether it's possible to regenerate the kind of momentum Superior Foes has been getting, especially considering the precarious position the title is in due to its low sales. That being said, it's good to see that Spencer and Lieber haven't lost their touch during their brief absence, and I'm eagerly looking forward to reading the next chapter in their amusing crime caper, especially since it's believed we might be getting the actual origin of Overdrive. Not to mention what actually did happen to Inspector that made Speed Demon cry? Do yourselves a favor and get some extra copies of this one to celebrate their return.